Mane
Mikayelyan
Tara
Phillips
19
October 2016
World War I greatly changed the
social dynamic of the United States. Since many men did not return home following
the war, women were often left alone or with few possible choices for suitors.
With the memory of the horrific war fresh in mind and the recent Spanish flu
epidemic, many young people felt that life was short and wanted to enjoy every
moment as if it were their last. Women no longer wanted to quietly sit around
and wait for men to court them. Their increased independence, recently achieved
suffrage, greater opportunity in the work field, and the growth of consumerism
promoted a hedonistic outlook on life. Women became less concerned with
pleasing their fathers and husbands, and more concerned with pleasing
themselves. Altogether, this essentially sparked the rise of the modern woman
and more specifically, the flapper.
The flapper directly opposed its predecessor,
known as the “Gibson girl.” Inspired by Charles Dana Gibson’s drawings, the
Gibson girl loosely styled her long hair on top of her head, wore a long
straight skirt, a high collar, and a corset to create a feminine yet modest
look. In contrast, the flapper chopped off her hair in a “bob,” “eton,” or
“shingle” cut, wore knee length skirts and dresses, wore more makeup, bared her
arms and collarbone to the public, and flattened her feminine curves by binding
her chest and wearing apparel with lower waistlines. The look was pioneered by
the French fashion artist, Coco Chanel and was known as “garconne,” meaning
“boy” in French. Indeed, the flapper’s straight torso and short hair made her
resemble a young boy. While the Gibson girl was quiet and submissive to men,
the flapper participated in “flapper flocks,” in which women empowered one
another and had control over male assistants known as “flippers,” breaking the
conventional male-female power dynamic.
After Coco Chanel showed off a new tan, tan
skin increased in popularity as it suggested a “life of leisure.” Life was no
longer just about work anymore; flappers were more concerned about having fun.
Flappers were actively engaged in the nightlife of the city and frequented jazz
clubs, vaudeville shows and speakeasies—illegal places to drink alcohol during
prohibition. Women smoked, drank, and danced more than ever before. They partook
in fast-paced dances such as the “Charleston,” and the “Black Bottom Shimmy,”
both of which were considered “wild” by older generations. Dancing was not the
only thing in their lives that was fast-paced—flappers were also quick to
engage in sexual activities. With the increased popularity of Sigmund Freud’s
declaration that the libido is “one of the most natural human needs,” women
felt encouraged to explore their sexualities. A new social interaction known as
a “petting party” emerged, where individuals engaged in activities such as
kissing and foreplay. Flappers no longer felt the need to repress their libido
as Victorian women once did, and along with increased use of birth control and
greater access to automobiles—which provided a new location for sexual
activity—unorthodox sexual activity increased exponentially. In fact, flappers
began to refer to wedding rings as “handcuffs,” indicating their disdain for
constricting limitations and traditionality of marriage.
As with anything that contradicts traditional
values and norms, flappers received their fair share of backlash. Critics
argued flappers were vapid and reckless, as they engaged in risky and wild
behavior but largely ignored serious matters such as politics. They were
attacked for acting like men instead of truly expressing themselves and were
seen as brash for their excessive makeup and disdain for what was considered
socially acceptable behavior. Yet despite all the controversy, the flapper
undoubtedly set the precedent for what we consider the modern woman today.
Flappers protested critiques of their behavior by arguing a double standard
existed that allowed people to ignore similar behavior in men. They scoffed at
previous generations of women and called them “clinging vines,” indicating
their disapproval of the dependence and passivity of the Victorian women.
I find the flapper particularly interesting
because of her unconventional interest in sexual activities and ability to put herself
first before others, both of which are characteristics our class has observed
in numerous female characters. In The 42nd Parallel, Annabelle
does not seem too concerned with the criticism she receives regarding her
promiscuity and independent nature. In Their
Eyes Were Watching God, Janie puts her own happiness before her reputation
and is in touch with the naturalness of her sexuality. Both of these characters
develop and exhibit modernist values. As the term “flapper” can often refer to
a young bird flapping its wings while learning to fly, flappers were truly the
pioneers for the modern independent woman.
Discussion
1) I find the flapper interesting as she seems like an exaggeration of the modern values found in many of the female characters we have studied so far. Which characters do you think embody which characteristics of the flapper?
2) Do you think flappers were solely preoccupied with having fun and deserved the criticism they received about being rude and vapid for not caring for political matters which previous generations of women were largely involved in?
1) I find the flapper interesting as she seems like an exaggeration of the modern values found in many of the female characters we have studied so far. Which characters do you think embody which characteristics of the flapper?
2) Do you think flappers were solely preoccupied with having fun and deserved the criticism they received about being rude and vapid for not caring for political matters which previous generations of women were largely involved in?
Works Cited
"Flapper." The Ultimate History Project. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Oct. 2016.
"Flapper." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, n.d. Web. 18 Oct. 2016.
"Flappers." Ushistory.org. Independence Hall Association, n.d. Web. 18 Oct. 2016.
Gibson, Charles D. Digital image. Wikipedia. N.p., n.d. Web. <https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fb/Gibson_Girls_seaside_-cropped-_by_Charles_Dana_Gibson.jpg>.
Good Time Girls. Digital image. Vintage Dancer. N.p., n.d. Web. <http://cdn.vintagedancer.com/wp-content/uploads/1920s-flapper-dances.jpg>.
"The New, Modern Woman: The Flapper." About.com Education. N.p., 28 June 2016. Web. 18 Oct. 2016.
Great post! I think flappers definitely show us an overall view of how women were slowly taking control of their lives in American at the time. The women in the books we've read are surely a more zoomed-in picture of the how life was slowly changing for women. It's nice to get so many interesting (and fun!) perspectives of the time, Thank you!
ReplyDeleteOut of the characters we have read about so far, I think Clare is most similar to a flapper. Like flappers who crossed gender boundaries through behaviors and appearance, Clare crosses racial boundaries through her actions and changing racial identity.
ReplyDeleteYour post was great and was written just in time when the world is experiencing new women empowerment movements. In my opinion, Flappers did not deserve the criticism that they received because, as you mentioned, they were experiencing independence that was never provided generations before them. Moreover, I agree with what you mentioned that how Flappers felt double standards concerning them and men existed in society, thus, a cause of harsh criticism. I think Clare, from "Passing", is an example of a flapper because she is independent and really is aware of her wants and needs is life.
ReplyDeleteI think flappers were not solely preoccupied with having fun, as they were making a statement as well. Like you said in your post, flappers "scoffed at previous generations of women and called them 'clinging vines.'" They wanted to show that women were strong and independent and change the view people had on women at that time.
ReplyDeleteI think it would be unfair to criticize these women as vapid when they were deciding to empower themselves and taking advantage of the freedoms that were not available to older women.
ReplyDeleteI believe that it was right for the women to express themselves the way they wanted to, especially since they felt very liberated by their actions. The confinement of their actions to stereotyped roles in society can limit their creativity, and I feel that this new-found freedom was better for women's rights as a whole.
ReplyDeleteI like how you drew the contrast between the flappers and Victorian women- I think that depicting that helps us understand how much of a departure from custom it was. I wonder how the flapper has influenced the image of women since then, and if we still carry some elements of their characterization in society today.
ReplyDeleteAwesome post! I like that you commend the flapper girl for being self-interested, which I think is something that to this day, women still get flack for much more than men. Regardless of how hedonistic or "vapid" they might seem, flapper girls represented values that at the very least, said that women were just as deserving of fun. Whether or not her actions were politically constructive, she represents an independence and defiance that instead of being internalized, was out in the public-eye, marking a departure from the cult of domesticity and facilitated the development of the modern woman.
ReplyDeleteAwesome post! I like that you commend the flapper girl for being self-interested, which I think is something that to this day, women still get flack for much more than men. Regardless of how hedonistic or "vapid" they might seem, flapper girls represented values that at the very least, said that women were just as deserving of fun. Whether or not her actions were politically constructive, she represents an independence and defiance that instead of being internalized, was out in the public-eye, marking a departure from the cult of domesticity and facilitated the development of the modern woman.
ReplyDeleteI think the concept of the flapper as a whole is an unfair criticism against women, as in 20th century society it was made to seem as if women were expected to place other above themselves. The act of self interest should be criticized as, after all, it is a basic human impulse that should not be ignored.
ReplyDeleteInteresting post! You did a good job analyzing the qualities of the new women of the early 20th century. I always found it fascinating how trends start in society so how you analyzed how the new woman of the 20th century arose was particularly interesting!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the post! I think it would be interesting to compare the different ways in which sexuality was changing during this time. Could this change towards a more accepting view of natural sexuality aid in the slow progression towards expression of homosexuality?
ReplyDelete